I don’t think I posted here, if I have, consider this an update!
Favorite pen liner - Jesse’s Girl (I WISH THEY SOLD THE BRAND HERE!!!)
Favorite brush liner - NYC Liquid Liner. I just started using this, and since it was only $2.49 at Target I bought both the matte black and the pearlized black. SO easy to use and looks amazing! Only downfall is it is not waterproof, so I have to set it with powder.
Favorite gel liner - L’Oreal Infallible Gel Laquer Liner. Not the easiest to use, but that’s user error, not the liner’s fault. I suck with pot liners, lol. Once it is on, though, this stuff does not budge and it is a nice, matte black. Best gel liner I’ve ever used, better that even the MUFE and NARS ones I tried.