I'm glad to hear that, because I was tempted to try marshmallow rose, but I really dislike headshop scents. I really don't care for HoG's rose note, which is a bummer, because I love rose. But theirs really doesn't even smell like rose to me - like sugared roses is supposed to be nothing but sugar and roses...but if I blind sniffed it, I'd never guess I was supposed to be smelling rose!
I also really dislike Sol. But I agree that Beguiled is really nice