Mine were super deflated when they arrived, but I love the texture and density that they ended up at. I'm waiting to see how long it takes me to use up a tub before judging though. I tend to go through them super slowly because I use them only as shaving cream and I don't shave that often. If it's about the same length of time as other ones, I'll probably repurchase. I'm actually almost worried that non-deflated ones will be too fluffed for my liking, lol! The scents I've tried have been amazing and much stronger than I expected, without lingering or interfering with perfume that I put on later.
I've got some gifts-for-others+impulsive-whipped-soaps-for-me orders coming from Valhalla Soaps and Solstice Scents too, so I'm interested to compare those formulas.