My favorite indie polish, hands down, is Native War Paints. Her formulas are consistently amazing and unique. My Favorite Sweater and Crisp Apples are two standouts, and the two eye shadows of hers that I have are also incredibly smooth and pigmented (the End of the Tracks duo.)
Second favorite is Pretty & Polished. Very unique and they have some really nice holos.
I would like RH a lot more if the formulas weren't such a damn gamble. Some are perfect, some require too much thinner to even be usable. And the swatches on the site can be just wrong imo. Their body stuff is great though.