First: Judge me if you must, but depending on the fabric, I might wear that dress until it fell apart. If it were like a jersey or t-shirty sort of material, I'd love it to death and wear it until it started pilling too much. If it's like a shiny prom dress material, then it would be a pass, mostly because I don't know where I'd wear it. Even with a shiny prom dress material, I'm just not getting the same prom dress vibe from the photo that everyone else is. It seems like the pleats would be the flattering sort, not the poofy awkward sort, but that might just be how those dresses tend to hang on my body, idk.
Second: I think I found it, and I think you can email them for store credit because it's priced so low. I found this one still on the site http://www.modcloth.com/shop/dresses/i-think-i-can-dress-in-pine Then I searched google for other colors of that dress, and was able to find this: http://www.modcloth.com/shop/dresses/i-think-i-can-dress-in-plum For some reason, the plum one is rated significantly lower, but I can't figure out how to read any of the reviews.