Good tip, @Shalott! Right now the indie perfume with the best staying power for me is Haus of Gloi. Darling Clandestine, Black Violet, and Bath Sabbath haven't lasted very long on me for some reason.
But back to bath and body, I hate to say it but none of the indies I've tried have the staying power that Lush has (which may be a good or bad thing depending on what your preferences are.) Like I have Queen Bee Apothecary's detangler and conditioner in their American Cream dupe (Vanilla Cream Soda maybe?) and it doesn't last in my hair like the real thing does.